Eternity presents itself at first as a whimsical romantic comedy centered on a woman’s dilemma between two men, but it goes deeper by exploring the essence of love. Directed by David Freyne and co-written with Pat Cunnane, the film invites viewers to ponder whether love thrives in passionate, fleeting moments or in the steady warmth of companionship forged through shared experiences. The central character, Joan, portrayed by Elizabeth Olsen, faces a week to decide between her long-time husband Larry (Miles Teller) and her first love Luke (Callum Turner), who has been waiting in the afterlife.
Typically, romantic comedies provide a clear trajectory toward an expected conclusion. However, Eternity cleverly subverts expectations by shifting viewer sympathies frequently, making it challenging to root for one character over another. The film compels audiences to grapple with the choices that define relationships, oscillating between fervent desire and the emotional stability that comes from lifelong partnerships.
In a twist of fate, Joan passes away shortly after the narrative unfolds, joined in the afterlife by Larry, who dies from a comedic mishap. The plot thickens with the revelation that Joan was previously married to Luke, a soldier who perished in the Korean War. This rekindles unresolved feelings, leaving Joan torn between the spontaneous joy of her past with Luke and the profound bond she shares with Larry. The stakes are high—she must make her decision knowing that there are no second chances.
The film introduces an intriguing concept of different potential eternities, each with its own unique charm, once Joan makes her choice. The characters grapple with insecurity and fear of solitude, leading to moments of unexpected camaraderie among the men vying for her affection. Though some comedic elements, delivered by characters like assistants Anna and Ryan, skew towards broad humor, the core of the screenplay remains sophisticated and thoughtful.
The chemistry among the lead actors adds depth to the narrative; Teller and Olsen exhibit a realistic rapport that reflects a lifetime spent together, while Turner embodies a poignant earnestness. Eternity stands out as a refreshing take on the romantic comedy genre, straying from clichés and offering a blend of unpredictability and warmth, all without succumbing to overt sentimentality.
In essence, Eternity manages to carve its unique space within the genre by marrying humor with meaningful questions about love and choice, ultimately revealing a good-heartedness that resonates with viewers.