The Penguin has remained a standout hit for DC Studios since it debuted on HBO last fall, earning widespread acclaim and a strong wave of Emmy momentum. The limited series has garnered 24 nominations, including Outstanding Limited or Anthology Series, with acting nods for Colin Farrell, Cristin Milioti, and Deirdre O’Connell, fueling talk of a potential second season or even a broader spin-off universe.
Cristin Milioti took the spotlight on The Today Show to celebrate her first Emmy nomination for The Penguin and to shed light on how she prepared for Sofia, the enigmatic ally-turned-friction point for the series. She shared that she enjoyed playing with Sofia’s look, including donning a wig, and she put real effort into mastering Sofia’s shifting accent. The biggest tease, however, centered on whether Sofia might return in future installments—be it another season or a spin-off pairing Sofia with Zoë Kravitz’s Catwoman.
“ Oh, I mean, it would be great. It would be a real, it would be a great time,” Milioti said when asked about the possibility of a Sofia-and-Catwoman collaboration. The interview then pressed for details on whether any conversations have occurred, prompting her to reply, “With who?” before adding, “Everyone knows I would love to revisit it.” While she is friends with Kravitz in real life, the actress offered no definitive confirmation of talks about reuniting the characters on screen. Nevertheless, she made clear that she’s ready and eager to return to Sofia for another season or even a feature if the right project comes together.
Given the current landscape, a Sofia-Catwoman crossover remains speculative. The Batman Part II is moving forward with filming slated to begin in spring 2026 for a 2027 release, a development that would understandably take precedence in DC’s plans. Yet the potential for Sofia to appear in the Batman universe persists as a tantalizing possibility. The Penguin’s finale already left a door open—the revelation that Sofia receives a letter from Catwoman, who is revealed to be her half-sister—fueling ongoing fan interest in a future convergence of the two characters. Farrell is confirmed to return for the sequel, which reinforces the likelihood that Sofia could re-enter the broader Gotham mythos down the line.
If there is a future for Sofia and Catwoman together, fans have reasons to stay optimistic. The prospect of crossovers has become a familiar pattern in superhero storytelling, and Milioti’s enthusiasm signals that the right conversations could unlock a compelling chapter for both characters. For now, there is no official confirmation, but the chatter itself keeps the momentum alive as production on The Batman Part II ramps up and DC continues to map its next steps for Gotham’s most intriguing players.
Additional notes for readers: The Emmy nominations for The Penguin underscore the series’ critical acclaim and its ability to extend the Batman mythos in new directions. As conversations continue behind the scenes, audiences can look forward to potential updates on Sofia’s fate—whether that leads to a fresh season, a spin-off, or a crossover that pits Sofia and Catwoman against the broader challenges of Gotham in a new light.
Summary: Cristin Milioti teased the possibility of revisiting Sofia in The Penguin, potentially teaming with Catwoman, but no official plans have been announced. With The Batman Part II on the horizon, any such project would require careful timing, yet fans remain hopeful about future crossovers that could expand the DC universe in fresh, exciting ways. Positive signs from Milioti and the ongoing success of The Penguin keep the door open for exciting developments ahead.