Eli Manning will have to wait at least another year for his induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, as he reportedly did not receive sufficient votes in his second year of eligibility. The two-time Super Bowl MVP’s omission comes as no surprise to many, given his .500 career record and his average standing in yearly passing statistics. Manning’s remarkable achievements, including game-winning drives in two Super Bowl victories against the Patriots and Tom Brady, have solidified his place in NFL lore, yet his candidacy remains one of the most complex among Hall of Fame nominees.
Despite his noteworthy achievements, Manning’s track record presents challenges. Hall of Fame quarterbacks typically boast impressive statistics and accolades, consistently ranking among the elite at their position. A closer look at Manning’s performance reveals he often fell short of these standards.
His average rank in expected points added per play (EPA per play) over his 16-year career was 18th, which is below average and notably lower than peers like Derek Carr. In adjusted net yards per pass attempt (ANY/A+), Manning again struggled, with an average rank of 17th, placing him behind Andy Dalton. Such rankings are critical; most Hall of Fame quarterbacks have consistently higher statistics, often finishing in the top 10.
Additionally, Manning’s average passer rating rank was 19th, which is less favorable than quarterbacks such as Carson Wentz. Notably, he had no top-five finishes in passer rating and only managed one top-10 finish, in 2011. A comparison with other Hall of Fame quarterbacks illustrates Manning’s difficulties in achieving consistent greatness.
As time passes, Manning’s chances for enshrinement may become more complicated with new legendary quarterbacks like Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, and Ben Roethlisberger joining the Hall of Fame conversation. These players also have impressive resumes that enhance the competition among nominees.
However, there are compelling arguments in Manning’s favor that could eventually lead to his induction. His durability, longevity, and significant contributions to the game cannot be overlooked. He is one of only six players to have multiple Super Bowl MVP awards, sharing that distinction with legends such as Tom Brady and Joe Montana. His iconic moments, particularly the unforgettable helmet catch in Super Bowl history and his precision passing, have a lasting impact on the NFL narrative.
Manning’s resilience is evidenced by his 210 consecutive regular-season starts, ranking him third in that category among quarterbacks, only behind Brett Favre and Philip Rivers. He retired rank among the top 10 all-time in passing touchdowns and passing yards, although these numbers will become less significant in the context of an evolving passing era.
The decision regarding Manning’s Hall of Fame candidacy will undoubtedly spark debates, as he embodies both outstanding achievements and some statistical shortcomings. Like Joe Namath, the last quarterback inducted with a losing record, Manning’s career has its similarities, particularly in the context of major Super Bowl performances that have defined him.
As he remains a part of the conversation about NFL greatness, it is clear that Eli Manning’s legacy will be remembered, and his story is undoubtedly intertwined with the heart and history of the sport. In the end, his remarkable highs may well carry him into football immortality.