In a closely contested matchup, the Philadelphia Eagles managed to secure a narrow 15-12 victory against the New Orleans Saints. While the win was critical, it was accompanied by several concerning signs, indicating that there were more negatives than positives in this performance.
Here are five key takeaways from the Eagles’ second win of the season.
1. Saquon Barkley and Dallas Goedert Were Game Changers
Head coach Nick Sirianni faced scrutiny after a lackluster performance, with quarterback Jalen Hurts throwing an interception and losing a fumble. With several key offensive players sidelined, it was Barkley and Goedert who played pivotal roles in the victory. Barkley rushed for 147 yards and scored both the game-winning touchdown and a two-point conversion. Notably, he delivered a significant 65-yard touchdown run in the fourth quarter.
Goedert shone as well, finishing the game with 10 catches for 170 yards. He emerged as Hurts’ primary receiving option, especially during the game-winning drive, where a key play allowed him to break free for a crucial 61-yard reception.
2. Risks on Fourth Down Didn’t Pay Off
The Eagles struggled offensively and failed to score in the first half, partly due to a failed fourth-down conversion deep in Saints territory. The decision to go for it was scrutinized, especially given the circumstances, including the absence of key players like A.J. Brown. Instead of risking a failed conversion, the Eagles could have opted for a field goal to tie the game.
In a similar scenario in the second half, Hurts took a sack on fourth down instead of attempting a relatively straightforward field goal. Ultimately, Sirianni faced backlash for his decisions, especially as his kicker, Jake Elliott, struggled with a long 60-yard attempt later in the game.
3. Defensive Improvements Were Notable
Despite allowing 91 points in their previous two games, the Eagles’ defense held the Saints to just 12 points, a significant improvement. While Jordan Davis recorded the team’s only sack, several players stood out defensively. Zack Baun made 13 tackles, and Jalen Carter contributed with two tackles for a loss and two pass deflections, showcasing the defense’s potential to step up when needed.
4. Impressive Commentary Team
The broadcast team of Joe Davis and Greg Olsen received praise for their performance during the game. Their chemistry and insight enhanced the viewing experience for fans. While Kevin Burkhardt, FOX’s current top play-by-play voice, has proven effective, Davis has shown he could excel in the NFL booth someday. Olson’s ability to provide valuable commentary has drawn comparisons to prominent analysts in the field, indicating a bright future for this booth.
5. Injury Concerns Loom for the Eagles
As the game progressed, the Eagles faced multiple injury concerns. A.J. Brown was sidelined temporarily as DeVonta Smith underwent concussion evaluation. Additionally, right tackle Lane Johnson was ruled out with a concussion after experiencing severe symptoms on the sideline. Britain Covey also missed the second half due to a shoulder issue, and right guard Mekhi Becton struggled with a finger injury.
If Brown is unable to return for the upcoming game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, the Eagles’ offense may face severe challenges in terms of depth and talent. Even if he recovers, Hurts may still be without key players as they prepare for their next matchup.