New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani recently found himself at odds with some of his close allies in Albany after endorsing Governor Kathy Hochul for re-election. While this decision was anticipated, given Mamdani’s need to collaborate with Hochul on his ambitious proposals, it has not garnered unanimous support among his fellow Democratic Socialists in the state Legislature. Instead, some members have provided critical feedback regarding Mamdani’s choice.
In an op-ed published in The Nation, Mamdani articulated his rationale for supporting Hochul, acknowledging their differing views on crucial issues such as taxing the wealthy. He wrote, “The temptation is to allow difference to turn into distrust,” highlighting his growing trust in Hochul’s willingness to engage in constructive dialogue that yields results. Hochul echoed a similar sentiment, as she previously endorsed Mamdani for mayor in an op-ed.
Despite Mamdani’s rising profile, criticism has emerged from within the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), particularly regarding perceived moderation in his stances since the election. State Senator Jabari Brisport, the first DSA member in the state Legislature to announce support for Lieutenant Governor Antonio Delgado in the gubernatorial race, voiced disapproval of Mamdani’s endorsement of Hochul. He remarked, “Even Zohran gets it wrong sometimes,” while emphasizing the collective strength of the movement that transcends individual endorsements.
Assembly Member Emily Gallagher, who also backed Delgado, expressed concern over Mamdani’s commitment to progressive values. Initially stating that the movement had placed its faith in Mamdani, she later requested that her critical comments be retracted, saying she was “upset” upon reflection after further discussion. In a revised statement, Gallagher softened her criticism and reiterated support for Mamdani, pointing out the complexities he faces as he transitions from legislator to executive.
Several other socialist lawmakers opted not to take a stance on the gubernatorial race. State Senator Julia Salazar described the situation as “very interesting and surprising” but refrained from further comment, while Assembly Member Claire Valdez, whom Mamdani supports in her congressional campaign, also indicated she won’t be making an endorsement shortly.
Amid the discord within the party, Mamdani’s endorsement of Hochul reflects the pragmatic approach he must take while balancing the demands of his constituents and his allies. Observers of this political moment are hopeful that the conversations sparked by these endorsements will pave the way for constructive policy dialogues that could benefit New Yorkers in the long run.