The Miami Dolphins are facing a pivotal challenge as they evaluate their quarterback situation following a disappointing loss to the Cincinnati Bengals. During this game, a moment highlighted the stark contrast between their current roster and other successful teams: Joe Burrow, faced with pressure, skillfully maneuvered out of a tight spot to complete a crucial pass, showcasing his ability to extend plays. Such agility is what the Dolphins desperately lack in their quarterback.
Historically, this problem surfaces most glaringly when the Dolphins face teams like the Buffalo Bills and New England Patriots, where quarterbacks like Josh Allen and potentially Drake Maye are capable of keeping plays alive through their athleticism. In contrast, Miami’s current quarterback, Tua Tagovailoa, struggles to escape pressure and extend drives effectively. Tagovailoa has shown glimpses of potential, particularly when in rhythm, but his lack of mobility and arm strength, compounded by a hip injury sustained during his college career, have hampered his ability to deliver under duress.
As the Dolphins look ahead, it is clear that a shift in their quarterback strategy is necessary. The ideal candidate would possess a blend of size, athleticism, and arm strength—qualities that Tagovailoa does not fully embody. With college teams increasingly adopting spread offenses, finding such quarterbacks has become more challenging. The upcoming offseason appears particularly daunting, as there are few enticing free-agent options and a draft class that has not lived up to expectations.
Several promising quarterbacks, including Arch Manning and LaNorris Sellers, have opted to remain in college, likely recognizing the benefits of further development before pursuing a professional career. Sellers, in particular, caught attention for his physical attributes but still requires refinement as a passer. Unfortunately, in the current NFL culture, patience for player development is dwindling, making it difficult for teams to invest in less experienced quarterbacks.
To enhance their chances of finding a suitable quarterback, the Dolphins need first to prioritize the hiring of a new general manager and coaching staff. The success of their future quarterback search will hinge on their ability to identify a player who can thrive in today’s game—not just making throws in the pocket, but also making plays with their legs to evade defenders and extend drives. Given the current landscape, it may take a year or so for the Dolphins to secure the talent they seek, especially considering their financial constraints and the potential need for draft picks to build a competitive roster.
Despite the challenges, this period can be a transformative time for the Dolphins, and with careful planning and strategic decisions, there is hope for revitalizing their offense and returning to contention in the league.