Toronto FC is on the lookout for a new starting goalkeeper, and Dayne St. Clair, fresh off a successful season as Minnesota United’s keeper, could be an ideal candidate for the role. Following his contract expiration, St. Clair is exploring options and will likely be in goal for Canada’s upcoming World Cup opener on June 12. His impressive performance last season, which earned him the MLS Goalkeeper of the Year title, has made him a highly sought-after asset in the league.
After declining Sean Johnson’s contract option in October, Toronto FC finds itself in a strategic position to pursue St. Clair. According to TSN’s Matthew Scianitti, multiple MLS clubs are vying for his signature, with Toronto being one of the strong contenders. Although Minnesota United remains interested in retaining him, St. Clair’s potential availability has sparked interest from teams both in the U.S. and abroad.
St. Clair, at 28, presents a unique blend of national team experience and MLS success, which is precisely what TFC needs as they head into the 2026 season. His track record as a reliable shot-stopper, combined with his impressive athleticism and improved game management, makes him a valuable candidate. His performances throughout 2025 have positioned him as a favorite to start in the 2026 FIFA World Cup, further boosting his appeal on the domestic front.
For a Toronto FC team that has faced considerable defensive challenges over the past two seasons, acquiring a goalkeeper of St. Clair’s caliber could be a game-changer, especially in light of Johnson’s departure. However, the competition for St. Clair’s services includes well-established franchises like Greg Vanney’s LA Galaxy and Jacob Shaffelburg’s Nashville SC, among others. TFC is currently in the early phases of a rebuild, which makes attracting a top-tier free agent particularly challenging.
What Toronto FC can offer St. Clair is a guaranteed starting position, the opportunity to return to his home region, and a chance to lead the club’s defensive rejuvenation efforts. The club’s leadership has indicated a willingness to be proactive this winter, and bringing in a Canadian international like St. Clair would align with the vision of building a stronger foundation rather than relying on temporary solutions. This move would not only enhance the team’s competitiveness but also solidify Toronto FC’s Canadian identity during a vital period for roster development.
Ultimately, whether St. Clair becomes available to TFC hinges on negotiations with Minnesota United. If they manage to sign him before he enters the open market, the opportunity for Toronto could swiftly diminish. However, if St. Clair does enter free agency, Toronto FC will likely make a compelling case to sign him, potentially transforming their defensive lineup.