The 2025 NFL season has proven to be a difficult one for the Dallas Cowboys, who currently hold a disappointing record of 6-7-1 amid a two-game losing streak that has nearly eliminated their chances of making the playoffs. While head coach Brian Schottenheimer has faced adversity during the season, the overall performance of the team has led to widespread disappointment among fans and analysts alike.
Despite some promising moments, several players have failed to meet expectations this season. Here’s a review of the five most disappointing players for the Cowboys so far:
Tyler Guyton, the offensive tackle and 2024 first-round pick, has struggled significantly in pass protection. Although he has dealt with injuries recently, his performance has not improved, with 31 pressures allowed thus far—surpassing the 26 he gave up during his rookie season. For the Cowboys’ offensive line to regain stability, they need Guyton to enhance his performance in the coming weeks.
Trade acquisition Kenneth Murray has also underperformed, failing to make a notable impact since joining the team from the Tennessee Titans. Managing to have a limited effect on both the run and pass defense, Murray’s struggles have been compounded by defensive coordinator Matt Eberflus’s reluctance to reduce his snap count, leaving fans questioning the decision to trade for him.
Defensive end Sam Williams, a second-round pick in 2022, has not capitalized on the opportunity presented to him following the trade of star player Micah Parsons. Despite having shown promise with 8.5 sacks in his first two seasons, Williams has struggled to produce this year, with only one sack and 19 tackles thus far. Although he has contributed to special teams with a punt block against the Arizona Cardinals, his performance on defense has not matched expectations.
Running back Jaydon Blue has experienced a disappointing start to his NFL career. Despite excitement surrounding his selection as a fifth-round pick due to his impressive speed and receiving ability, Blue has only registered 65 yards on 22 attempts this season, playing in just four games. He has lost his job to Malik Davis, raising concerns about his future with the Cowboys.
Lastly, cornerback Trevon Diggs has faced a challenging season, hindered by knee injuries and lingering concussion issues that placed him on injured reserve. Having participated in only six games, Diggs has struggled to make his presence felt, contributing to an underwhelming performance from the Dallas secondary. The uncertain dynamics between Diggs and the front office also point towards a potential change on the horizon as the team looks to restructure for the following seasons.
Despite the trials and tribulations this season, Cowboys owner Jerry Jones remains optimistic about the team’s future. As the Cowboys prepare to face the Los Angeles Chargers in Week 16, fans hope that the team can turn things around and build a stronger foundation moving forward.