The Indianapolis Colts are facing significant challenges regarding the future of quarterback Anthony Richardson as they approach the 2025 offseason. With just two games left in the season, the questions surrounding Richardson’s potential to become the franchise quarterback are escalating.
Recently, Richardson was ruled out for a game against the New York Giants due to back and foot injuries, which have become emblematic of his struggles during this season. Head coach Shane Steichen indicated that the back injury, particularly spasms affecting his mobility, is more concerning in the short term. This marks the fourth injury during Richardson’s brief NFL career, leading him to miss 16 of 33 possible starts.
Despite Colts management downplaying concerns over Richardson’s health and durability as a quarterback known for his physical style, the accumulating injuries have raised legitimate questions. The inability to stay healthy is critical for any player, especially a quarterback. Indianapolis owner Jim Irsay emphasized the importance of health at the quarterback position, echoing similar sentiments about franchise quarterbacks in the past.
Additionally, Richardson’s inexperience and struggles with accuracy have compounded the issues. Despite the Colts’ initial belief in his potential when they drafted him fourth overall in 2023, Richardson’s performance has been inconsistent. He completed just 47.7% of his throws this season, significantly lower than his rookie completion rate. This has contributed to the team’s offensive struggles, including several three-and-outs and a lack of explosive plays.
Despite these challenges, Richardson still possesses a significant upside. He is a powerful and dynamic player, capable of making big plays and avoiding sacks – a skill that many young quarterbacks take time to develop. However, it’s evident the Colts may have to regroup and provide him with further opportunities for growth without the option of a clear upgrade through free agency or the draft.
As the Colts consider their options, many believe that giving Richardson another chance may be the best approach. His potential remains, but it will require addressing the same issues that have hindered his development thus far.
Looking forward, the Colts face a crucial decision-making period that will shape their future. There is hope that with time, patience, and the right support, Richardson can evolve into the quarterback the franchise needs. As they move ahead, fostering his development will be key to turning potential into performance and ensuring the team has a bright future ahead.