The preseason Coaches Poll’s top 25 rankings were released this past Monday, providing college football enthusiasts with an initial glimpse into the standings ahead of the 2025 season. In a historic moment for Texas, the Longhorns secured their first-ever preseason No. 1 ranking, narrowly edging out the reigning national champion Ohio State. Following these two teams are heavyweights like Georgia, Notre Dame, and Oregon, which have consistently been in contention.
While many of the teams in the top seven are recognized perennial playoff contenders, the poll’s rankings have sparked debate regarding the assessment of certain teams. Analyzing the initial Coaches Poll reveals several teams that may be seen as either overrated or underrated this season.
Overshadowed by buzz, South Carolina ranks No. 13, despite their strong playmakers, including quarterback LaNorris Sellers and edge rusher Dylan Stewart. The Gamecocks had a successful 9-3 season last year, but their ranking raises questions, especially considering they are placed ahead of previous College Football Playoff competitors and conference champions like Boise State and Iowa State.
Conversely, Clemson finds itself at No. 6, which some may argue is an undervalued position. With returning quarterback Cade Klubnik showcasing first-round NFL Draft potential and a solid roster of wide receivers, offensive linemen, and defensive talent, the Tigers are poised to exceed expectations in a highly competitive landscape.
Michigan, ranked No. 14, witnessed promising momentum with their recent coaching changes and player acquisitions, yet skepticism remains regarding the supporting cast surrounding freshman quarterback Bryce Underwood. The Wolverines face challenges with key player departures on both offense and defense, suggesting their ranking may be too lofty at this point.
On the other hand, Iowa State is highlighted as an undervalued team at No. 21, demonstrating a strong history with seven successful seasons in eight years. The return of 14 starters, including key offensive and defensive players, positions them as a potential surprise contender this season.
Tennessee’s placement at No. 18 raises eyebrows as well, especially with their offensive struggles and uncertainties at quarterback. The Vols must overcome significant challenges, including player injuries and depth issues, to prove their ranking is justified.
In contrast, Louisville is gaining attention with Coach Jeff Brohm at the helm, showcasing a talented roster including USC transfer quarterback Miller Moss and promising running back Isaac Brown. With solid production expected from the offense and a dynamic linebacker duo, Louisville could well become a dark horse in the playoff conversation as the season progresses.
Overall, with various opinions on the rankings, the Coaches Poll serves as just the starting point for a thrilling college football season ahead, and many teams will undoubtedly look to defy expectations as they battle for glory on the field.