Cleveland Mayor Justin Bibb has sent a letter to Browns owners Jimmy and Dee Haslam, threatening legal action under Ohio Revised Code 9.67, known as the “Art Modell law.” The letter demands that the Browns provide the city with an opportunity to purchase the franchise if they intend to relocate. Bibb has set a deadline of January 9 for the Browns to respond, warning that failure to do so may lead to legal action, including a possible court petition to halt relocation efforts.
The backdrop of this dispute is the Browns’ consideration of a new stadium in Brook Park, located about 15 miles from Cleveland, despite the franchise being bound by a lease to play at Huntington Bank Field until after the 2028 season. The Browns recently filed a lawsuit against the city, arguing that the Modell Law is unconstitutional and asserting that they have complied with its requirements.
The “Art Modell law” was enacted after the Browns’ original owner relocated the team to Baltimore in 1995, with the intention of making it harder for other sports teams to move out of Ohio. The law mandates that any Ohio-based team intending to move from a tax-supported facility must notify the government six months in advance and offer the team for sale to local buyers. There is some ambiguity about what constitutes “elsewhere,” which has led to further complications.
Bibb’s letter requests specific dates for discussions regarding the evaluation of the Browns’ records, asserting the need for transparency in this process. The legal implications of the Modell Law with regard to the Browns’ potential relocation remain largely unexplored, especially since past disputes have favored settlements rather than judicial determination.
Peter John-Baptiste, chief communications officer for Haslam Sports Group, acknowledged receipt of Bibb’s letter and stated that the team has every intention of meeting their current lease obligations while investigating long-term solutions for their stadium needs.
The ongoing dialogue presents a significant opportunity for both the city and the franchise to collaboratively address concerns regarding the future of NFL in Cleveland, potentially fostering an environment of mutual benefit.
In summary, Cleveland’s mayor is seeking assurance from the Browns about their intentions and compliance with local laws as the franchise explores options for a new stadium, while both sides prepare for potential legal proceedings over the matter.