“Caroline 2” is a striking sequel that captures the essence of its creators—the London octet known for their deep emotional connections in post-rock. This album is bolder, brighter, and more ambitious than its predecessor while still embracing a sense of earnest wonder that has defined the band’s sound. The song “Good Morning (Red)” reflects this evolution; originally inspired by a political awakening during the 2017 Labour Party canvassing, it has transformed into an elegy that resonates with the collective idealism of the band.
While earlier works occasionally prioritized process over product, “Caroline 2” showcases a refined balance between meticulous analog improvisation and carefully crafted digital production. The band’s influences, previously shunned in favor of a unique identity, now embrace elements reminiscent of American Football and other seminal acts—creating a blend of yearning melodies and straightforward, heartfelt lyrics.
The opening track, “Total Euphoria,” stands out as a mesmerizing anthem, where the band’s unquantized playing creates an experience that feels as if multiple musicians are recording separately. The tension it builds is palpable, culminating in a moment that reflects both the triumph of success and the tranquility of acceptance. In contrast, “Song Two” introduces dissonant strings that evoke unease yet transforms into a sunlight-filled release, exemplifying the band’s ability to navigate complex emotions through sound.
Overall, “Caroline 2” not only showcases the band’s growth but also their commitment to exploring the profound themes of existence, potentially offering listeners a refreshing perspective amidst the chaos of the modern world. This album illustrates the beauty of collaboration and the power of music to evoke shared sentiments, leaving fans hopeful for what lies ahead in this collective journey.