During the 2025 season, the St. Louis Cardinals have surprised many by not only remaining competitive in the National League Central division but also avoiding the anticipated decline that some experts predicted. General managers around the league are expressing frustration over the Cardinals’ unwillingness to embrace a losing season, which would typically set the stage for a rebuilding phase.
The Cardinals’ leadership, led by president of baseball operations John Mozeliak, aims to keep the season exciting and competitive rather than falling into the trap of a rebuild. This unexpected success has spurred speculation in the trade market, particularly concerning key players like Nolan Arenado and closer Ryan Helsley. Although Arenado has been mentioned in trade discussions, interest from other teams appears lukewarm. Opposing teams may find it difficult to acquire top talent from St. Louis, as the Cardinals’ successful season has raised the stakes for any potential trades.
Jeff Passan from ESPN highlighted that St. Louis’ elite defense has played a crucial role in their success this year. One general manager admitted that the Cardinals’ unexpectedly strong performance complicates their plans as they approach the trade deadline, expressing frustration that a team expected to regress has instead thrived.
The Cardinals finished second in the division last year, which has provided a foundation for their current performance. With a solid lineup featuring veterans like Arenado and Helsley, the team is poised to continue competing for a playoff spot. However, holding onto their wild card position will require consistent contributions from both young and veteran players.
The Cardinals have a real opportunity to make a playoff run if they can maintain their momentum and continue to develop their younger talent while relying on the stability of their experienced players. This combination could make them formidable contenders in the wild card race as the season progresses.