Cam Newton has emerged as a prominent critic of quarterback Drake Maye, frequently downplaying Maye’s contributions to the New England Patriots’ success this season. Newton, a former NFL MVP, has labeled Maye a game manager rather than a game-changer and suggested that he does not belong among the top five quarterbacks in the league. His perspective has focused on the importance of the Patriots’ defense in their playoff run to Super Bowl 60.
On his “4th & 1” podcast, Newton drew comparisons between Maye and previous quarterbacks who succeeded due to strong defensive support. He referenced players like Trent Dilfer, Jim McMahon, and Rex Grossman, who, despite their inconsistent performances, achieved Super Bowl success largely because of their defenses. “That’s just facts. Does that make Drake Maye a bad player? No. Did Drake Maye do enough to win a football game? Yes. But I would also say Drake Maye did enough to lose a game that he won, too,” Newton remarked.
Historically, Grossman led the Chicago Bears to the Super Bowl in the 2006 season, despite throwing 23 touchdowns against 20 interceptions, while Dilfer had a similar experience in 2000 with the Baltimore Ravens. Such comments suggest that Newton believes Maye’s achievements are innately tied to the team’s defensive prowess.
In the lead-up to Super Bowl 60, which features the Patriots facing the Seattle Seahawks, betting lines have set the over/under at 45.5 points, reflecting the high-stakes nature of the matchup. Despite the critiques, Maye has put up impressive statistics this season, tallying 31 touchdowns against just eight interceptions and throwing for 4,394 yards, placing him fourth in the NFL. His 77.1 QBR also led the league, showcasing his potential.
Moreover, New England’s defense has demonstrated exceptional performance throughout the season and playoffs. Key defensive plays, including a pivotal interception by Christian Gonzalez in the AFC Championship Game against the Denver Broncos, have helped secure the Patriots’ positions. Maye and the Patriots now face a significant test against the Seahawks, yet they have consistently found ways to prevail in crucial moments.
In a somewhat conciliatory note, Newton acknowledged Maye’s potential, predicting a promising future for the young quarterback. “But this is what you have to understand about ol’ Drake Maye,” Newton stated. “If he keeps this up with this trajectory, winning this early in his career, whether I like it, whether I love it, whether I hate it, hate it some more, hate it even more than that, despise it or just don’t wanna give credit when credit’s due, Drake Maye will go down as an all-time great. Even superseding the individual that played there that got a statue.” That individual is none other than the legendary Tom Brady.
As the narrative unfolds, Maye has a chance to silence critics and solidify his place in NFL history, particularly with the looming Super Bowl challenge ahead. The interplay between player development, team dynamics, and the influence of strong defense adds a compelling layer to this season’s storylines.