Joni Mitchell’s unique sound and signature style have made her a lasting influence in the music industry, inspiring countless artists over the years. Among those deeply affected by her artistry is Brandi Carlile, who regards Mitchell as a major benchmark for her own work.
In a recent interview, Carlile expressed the heartfelt respect she holds for Mitchell, stating that the legendary artist has shaped her writing process profoundly. “There are songs that just don’t get through the filter anymore of, ‘Can I drive up to that gate and play this song for Joni over a glass of wine?’” she shared. If a song cannot meet that standard, Carlile chooses not to write it, highlighting the high bar that Mitchell sets for her.
Carlile described her creative metric as a personal and intuitive process. “I don’t really understand the metric of how I judge those things. It just has to do with how I feel when I’m playing them,” she noted, reflecting on the emotional connection that drives her songwriting.
Drawing a whimsical distinction, Carlile articulated the difference between what she calls “the muse” and “the ick.” She explained that a song could be simple and stripped down, yet if it originates from genuine inspiration—the muse—it holds weight, whereas if it’s created from a place of trying to please others—it becomes ‘the ick,’ which she cannot support.
The bond between these two remarkable musicians extends beyond admiration. Their friendship was evident when Carlile encouraged Mitchell to take the stage at the Newport Folk Festival in 2022, marking her return after a twenty-year hiatus. The performance was a poignant moment, with Mitchell delighting fans by performing classics like “Big Yellow Taxi” and “A Case of You.”
Carlile’s efforts not only rekindled Mitchell’s passion for performing but also demonstrated the deep respect and admiration she has for the musical legend. This connection between the two artists showcases the power of mentorship and inspiration in the music industry, offering hope to those who seek to follow in the footsteps of their idols.