As the season progresses, several pitchers are making their way back from injuries and attempting to reclaim their spots in the rotation. This overview highlights three notable starters — Lance McCullers Jr., Spencer Strider, and Tony Gonsolin — each grappling with challenges after undergoing surgeries.
Lance McCullers Jr. of the Houston Astros has returned to Major League Baseball following right elbow surgery, marking his first appearances since late 2022. Though he faced setbacks in his recovery, he has managed to start six games this season, posting a 3.93 Fielding Independent Pitching (FIP) rate and a strikeout rate of 29%. However, he has exhibited decreased velocity, with his fastball averaging around 91-92 mph, compared to 93 mph prior to his injury. This reduction has affected both his sinker and slider, especially against right-handed hitters, where his performance has notably declined (5.31 FIP this season versus 3.81 FIP historically). McCullers has shown improvement in command during recent starts but still needs to refine his slider mechanics and regain full command to position himself as a dependable mid-rotation starter moving forward.
Spencer Strider, with the Atlanta Braves, has similarly faced hurdles after missing most of the previous season due to UCL surgery. His return this year has been limited to just four starts, averaging a 6.39 FIP and a 23% strikeout rate. Strider’s fastball, impressive in 2023 at 98 mph, has now decreased in velocity. His pitch shapes have evolved with new movement patterns, yet he struggles with command and location. Much like McCullers, Strider’s path to success hinges on regaining velocity and improving command, especially given that his effectiveness is closely tied to his ability to place his four-seamer more strategically in the zone.
Tony Gonsolin from the Los Angeles Dodgers has also been on an uneven return, battling issues related to right elbow discomfort after enduring Tommy John surgery in 2024. Through seven starts, Gonsolin holds a 5.96 FIP and a 24% strikeout rate. He’s demonstrated improved velocity that mirrors his 2022 performance; however, inconsistencies with mechanics and pitch tunneling are impacting his command significantly. The slider’s reduced effectiveness is a concern, yet his splitter has shone as a reliable pitch this season, boasting an impressive whiff rate. Despite facing challenges against left-handed hitters, there are encouraging signs that Gonsolin can still recapture his pre-injury form with targeted adjustments.
In conclusion, while each pitcher is still navigating their unique recovery journeys, there are glimpses of potential that suggest brighter days are ahead. The key for McCullers, Strider, and Gonsolin will be their ability to refine their command and adapt their pitching strategies, all while remaining healthy as the season unfolds.