The Houston Astros are facing a challenging offseason as they navigate towards the Competitive Balance Tax (CBT) threshold. With their 2026 payroll projected at approximately $238.4 million, the team is on the verge of exceeding the first CBT level, which stands at $244 million. Team owner Jim Crane has expressed a desire to keep the franchise under this tax, putting additional pressure on the front office to either trade players or make strategic cuts.
One player at the center of the conversation is backup catcher Victor Caratini, who signed a two-year contract earlier this offseason valued at an average annual salary of $6 million. Unless the Astros can find a solution to clear payroll, securing Caratini’s return for the 2026 season may not be feasible. This situation is further complicated by the fact that Caratini is not just a capable catcher; his versatility allows him to play first base and serve as a designated hitter, making him an attractive option for various teams.
Initially, it seemed that re-signing Caratini could be a priority for Houston, especially given their need for depth behind the plate. However, with his market presence still lingering, it appears that there might not be an immediate spot for him as a starter elsewhere, which may open the door for the Astros.
If the Astros are not willing to rely on César Salazar as a backup option, this might serve as an impetus to trade Isaac Paredes or Christian Walker to create the necessary financial flexibility. Moving Paredes could not only free up some cap space but also help establish a clearer direction for the franchise moving forward.
As the offseason unfolds, it remains to be seen how the Astros will balance their financial considerations with the goal of maintaining a competitive roster. The potential for change is on the horizon, and with decisions yet to be made, the outlook for the team’s future remains hopeful despite current challenges.