Andrew Garfield and Monica Barbaro have once again ignited rumors regarding their relationship as they were recently seen enjoying a night out on Broadway. The pair attended a performance of the Buena Vista Social Club at the Schoenfeld Theatre in New York City on May 11.
After the show, Garfield and Barbaro mingled backstage, interacting with cast members and snapping photos alongside Isa Antonetti and choreographer Justin Peck. Garfield embraced a laid-back style for the evening, donning a black T-shirt, white pants, and a navy cap, while Barbaro opted for a stylish glossy black trench coat.
Despite frequent sightings together, the actors have chosen to keep their relationship private. Their initial public appearance occurred on January 4 during W Magazine’s Best Performances party in Los Angeles, alongside other celebrities like Eddie Redmayne. Since then, the duo has been spotted at various events, including an exclusive Oscars afterparty hosted by Beyoncé and Jay-Z following the 2025 Academy Awards.
Other notable appearances include attending theater shows such as Oh, Mary! at the Lyceum Theatre and John Proctor Is the Villain. Just before their Broadway outing, the couple shared a tender moment on May 7 while heading to Maybe Happy Ending. Although they did not walk the 2025 Met Gala red carpet together, a video surfaced showing Garfield waiting for Barbaro outside The Mark Hotel, where he greeted her with a hug.
As of now, neither Garfield nor Barbaro has publicly addressed their relationship, leaving fans intrigued about this blossoming connection. The continued public interest reflects the excitement surrounding their potential partnership as they navigate both personal and professional realms together.