Shane Smith of the Chicago White Sox has been selected for the 2025 AL All-Star team, despite recent struggles on the mound. His inclusion is surprising given his last four starts, which have all been below average, raising doubts about whether he was the right choice to represent the team. While Smith has more starts than Adrian Houser, who might have been a more deserving pick at this stage, the selection opens discussion around the merit of all-star nominations.
A standout performer on the team who arguably deserves recognition is reliever Steven Wilson, boasting an impressive 1.5 WAR and a 1.59 ERA over 30 appearances. His impressive performance this season contrasts sharply with Smith’s recent slump, marked by two losses and an alarming 11.00 ERA over his last two starts.
Smith started the season strong, maintaining an ERA below 3.00 through his initial 14 starts. However, recent outings have diminished his record, leaving him with a season total of 3-7 and a 4.20 ERA as of Sunday. Despite this, his journey as a former No. 1 Rule 5 pick showcases the ups and downs of a baseball career, and his All-Star nod could serve as motivation for a stronger performance in the second half of the season.
For White Sox fans, the All-Star Game in Atlanta next week presents a hopeful opportunity for Smith to bounce back and regain his earlier form, potentially reigniting his season after a tough stretch. As the All-Star Game approaches, both fans and teammates will be eager to see how this experience might propel him forward.