Two of the three Alexander brothers, Oren and Alon, entered not guilty pleas on Tuesday to a recently added charge of sexual abuse by physical incapacitation, which is included in an 11-count indictment against them and their older brother, Tal. This latest allegation follows the superseding indictment filed in federal court on Monday and comes just weeks ahead of their federal sex trafficking trial.
The indictment alleges that in January 2012, the twins engaged in a sexual act with a woman who was reportedly incapable of declining participation aboard a cruise ship registered in the Bahamas, which traveled between the United States and other destinations.
The brothers are already facing serious charges related to a decade-long conspiracy involving the drugging, sexual assault, and rape of numerous women across locations including Miami, New York, and the Hamptons. Tal and Oren Alexander are both well-known real estate brokers in the luxury market, while Alon Alexander works for a family-run private security company.
According to prosecutors, the three brothers collaborated with others to systematically drug and assault women, often using the lure of luxurious experiences and accommodations to entice their targets. The indictment details instances where women were violently assaulted, sometimes by multiple attackers, including the Alexanders.
All three brothers have maintained their innocence concerning the other counts as well. Their attorney, Marc Agnifilo, opted not to comment following the court proceedings.
In a statement, their parents, Shlomi and Orly Alexander, expressed their unwavering belief in their sons’ innocence and described the emotional toll the ongoing ordeal has had on their family since the allegations were first made public. They urged that their sons be assessed on the evidence presented in court, rather than public speculation.
During the court proceedings, there were discussions regarding trial logistics, such as jury selection and the possibility of allowing certain alleged victims to testify anonymously to protect their identities. Judge Valerie Caproni displayed frustration at times over the discussions regarding jury questions, emphasizing the clear understanding that any unwanted physical contact constitutes sexual assault.
Defense attorney Teny Geragos raised concerns about the prosecution’s delays in providing essential materials, including videos and photos. The prosecution responded by asserting their commitment, stating that a number of FBI agents are dedicated to the case, despite the complexities involved.
Currently, all three brothers remain detained at the Metropolitan Detention Center in New York City as they prepare for trial, which is set to start with jury selection on January 20 and the trial beginning on January 26. The upcoming trial will serve as a critical moment for the defendants, and the court proceedings may lead to significant implications for all parties involved.