Contributing columnist Jay Michaelson reflects on the complexities surrounding Rosh Hashanah this year. As Jewish families gather for the holiday, tensions escalate with the threat of missiles over Israel and ongoing conflicts, particularly with Hamas still holding Israeli hostages. The anniversary of the October 7 attack looms, adding to the disorientation many feel.
A friend’s wish for a “sweet new year full of good adventures” humorously altered to “a sweet new tearful” encapsulates the mood of confusion and concern. This year’s conflict has heightened distress among American Jews, with differing views on previous wars and calls for resolutions from the Netanyahu government.
While Israel’s actions against Hezbollah have been more focused compared to the destructive impact of the Gaza conflict, civilian casualties remain a heartbreaking reality. Hezbollah, seen as a violent theocratic group serving Iran’s interests, adds another layer of complexity to the situation. The strategic decisions made by Israel in this instance have garnered mixed reactions, even among progressives.
Trust in the Netanyahu administration is waning, especially with potential escalations in Southern Lebanon. The looming threat from Iran is also concerning, as military responses from both sides create a backdrop of anxiety. Individuals with ties to Israel express heartache over the distress experienced by loved ones in the region.
This year, the mixture of heartbreak, anxiety, and ambivalence is palpable, intertwining support for Israel with deep concerns for innocent lives affected by the violence. The traditional reflection prompted by Rosh Hashanah contrasts the joy of family gatherings with the distress of world events, as individuals face multiple stressors, including political climates and social issues.
Despite the heavy realities, the cyclical nature of time and weariness from tumultuous seasons bring a sense of resilience. The acknowledgment of interconnected experiences, both personal and collective, plays a crucial role in navigating the emotional complexities of the moment. As Rosh Hashanah approaches, many are left contemplating the future while hoping for peace and understanding. Shana Tova.