Rosh Hashanah often presents a complex blend of emotions—joy, solemnity, celebration, and repentance. However, this year feels especially disorienting.
As Jews gather for the holiday, tensions are high, with the possibility of missiles flying between Israel and Iran. With the anniversary of October 7 approaching and Israeli hostages still held by Hamas, there is a shared sense of confusion and apprehension among many. A friend recently sent me a greeting intended to express wishes for a “sweet new year full of good adventures,” which somehow autocorrected to “a sweet new tearful,” perfectly capturing this year’s mood.
The recent escalation in the conflict has intensified the emotional toll on American Jews. The Gaza war was marked by significant tragedy with extensive loss of life, but the current situation feels different. Israel’s actions against Hezbollah have been more measured, though the loss of innocent life is always a tragedy. Hezbollah, a group widely regarded as a terrorist organization, does not represent the Palestinian struggle but serves Iran’s interests for regional power.
Many progressives acknowledged Israel’s tactical targeting of Hezbollah last month, despite some innocent collateral damage. The justification for these actions remains contentious, especially given the mistrust of the Netanyahu government. While Israel has thus far refrained from a full-scale invasion of Southern Lebanon, the political landscape remains fluid, and concerns linger about the potential for escalation.
There are competing emotions: heartbreak for those sheltering in fear, anxiety about the uncertain future, support for Israel balanced against skepticism of its leadership, and ongoing concern for Gaza residents and hostages. Amid this turmoil, there is also the familiar appeal of Rosh Hashanah inviting self-reflection, alongside the traditional joys of sharing meals and celebrating with loved ones.
Adding to the complexity, we navigate the backdrop of an impending American election, climate-driven disasters, rising antisemitism, and the daily stresses of modern life. It’s a lot to process, even more so for those directly impacted by conflict and hardship in places like Beersheva and Beirut.
What brings me solace is recognizing the cyclical nature of time and the enduring values at the heart of Rosh Hashanah. In the midst of chaos, there exists a potential for peace within. As Ecclesiastes notes, “the wind spins around, and the wind returns.”
While the future remains uncertain, cultivating resilience and awareness of the present moment is crucial. For now, I extend wishes for a Shana Tova, a good year ahead.