Nick Castellanos finds himself at a crossroads with the Philadelphia Phillies as he becomes increasingly likely to be either released or traded ahead of spring training. President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski confirmed on Monday that the team is actively seeking a change of scenery for Castellanos, signaling that he is no longer a part of the organization’s future plans despite the continued need for right-handed offense in the lineup.
The situation is particularly frustrating for the Phillies, as Castellanos once had the potential to be the impactful player they believed they were acquiring four years ago. Currently, the team struggles to solidify the cleanup spot behind their top hitters, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber, and Bryce Harper. The need for right-handed protection, especially in crucial moments, makes the unfulfilled expectations surrounding Castellanos all the more disappointing for the franchise.
In looking at potential replacements for the cleanup role in 2026, names like Alec Bohm and Adolis Garcia emerge as candidates, with Bohm likely taking the lead due to his consistent contact and effectiveness with runners in scoring position.
As for a potential trade involving Castellanos, it feels as though the front office is more focused on resolving the issue rather than maximizing return value at this stage. With the full squad set to report for spring training soon, the Phillies may prefer to expedite a resolution to avoid any distractions. Ideally, they would like to trade Castellanos for a player another team has soured on or to relieve some of his $20 million salary. Even a modest return—a financial break or a minor asset—would be viewed as preferable to letting the matter linger unresolved.
Interestingly, there remains the possibility that an injury during spring training for another team could elevate Castellanos’ desirability, should the Phillies choose to keep him on the roster a bit longer. For a player who has been with the organization for four years, waiting any further may be frustrating for Castellanos, who is eager to commence the season, whether with the Phillies or elsewhere.
Potential trade partners have included teams like the Pittsburgh Pirates, who recently signed Marcell Ozuna, and the Miami Marlins, Castellanos’ hometown team. The Atlanta Braves, who have shown little offensive activity this offseason, could also explore the option. Not to mention, several clubs in the American League Central may find Castellanos to be a fitting addition to their rosters.
If the Phillies opt to release Castellanos, many teams would likely vie for him at the league minimum. Despite the criticisms surrounding his performance, there is an understanding that he can still deliver explosive offensive moments when he finds his rhythm at the plate. For Castellanos, a release may represent an opportunity to choose a situation that offers the most playing time.
Drafted 44th overall in 2010 by a Tigers team led by Dombrowski, Castellanos has shared a lengthy professional relationship with the current Phillies president, having spent nine of his 16 seasons with Dombrowski’s guidance. With open communication between both parties, there appears to be a mutual desire to reach a resolution, making the timing of both a trade and potential opportunities critical for Castellanos’ next career chapter.