The Carolina Panthers made headlines during the 2025 NFL Draft by selecting wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan with the No. 8 overall pick, diverging from the expected focus on defense. This decision came after a tumultuous season under defensive coordinator Ejiro Evero, whose squad struggled to meet expectations. General manager Dan Morgan’s choice raised eyebrows, especially following last year’s move to draft a wide receiver instead of bolstering the defense. However, Morgan’s unconventional approach appears to be paying off as McMillan has emerged as a key player for the team.
McMillan made an immediate impact upon joining the Panthers, showcasing a blend of aggression, skill, and reliability that quickly endeared him to fans. He broke the franchise record for rookie receiving yards, previously held by Kelvin Benjamin, amassing an impressive 1,014 yards on 70 receptions, while also scoring seven touchdowns. His performance not only solidified his position as the team’s primary receiver but also played a crucial role in leading the Panthers to their first postseason appearance since 2017.
Analysts have highlighted McMillan’s contributions, with Sportsnaut’s Matt Johnson labeling him as a frontrunner for the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year. Johnson emphasized that despite late-season competition from New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough, McMillan’s consistent and impactful performance throughout the season stands out. With six games featuring over 70 receiving yards, his ability to convert 122 targets into significant yardage has been instrumental for the Panthers.
McMillan’s success has also shone a light on the struggles of other receivers on the roster, as both Xavier Legette and Jalen Coker faced challenges this season. Without McMillan’s contributions, the Panthers’ passing attack would likely have suffered greatly. Finishing as the No. 14 receiver in the league for yards gained as a rookie is a remarkable feat, and experts believe that with continued development, particularly in route running and red-zone efficiency, McMillan’s potential is boundless.
The Panthers’ decision to invest in McMillan has already proven fruitful, suggesting a bright future for both the player and the team. The recognition of his performance with the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year award would be a fitting acknowledgment of his remarkable first season and the pivotal role he has played in revitalizing the Panthers’ offense.