As the NFL season reaches its midpoint, team evaluations are in full swing, revealing a mix of surprising successes and disheartening struggles. The 2025 campaign has exposed a landscape of parity across the league, with every team experiencing at least two losses, complicating assessments as contenders fluctuate from week to week. However, the sample size is large enough for a more accurate grading of each franchise against their preseason expectations.
The Indianapolis Colts, New England Patriots, and Seattle Seahawks have all outperformed expectations, earning solid “A” grades. The Colts’ impressive start, despite a notable six-turnover loss to the Steelers, showcases a highly efficient offense led by Daniel Jones and a bolstered defense with the addition of two-time All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner. The Patriots, under Mike Vrabel, have introduced a legitimate MVP candidate in Drake Maye, showcasing a turnaround that has reestablished their status in the AFC East. The Seahawks have also dazzled, transforming their offense and demonstrating formidable resiliency on the road.
On the other end of the spectrum, the Tennessee Titans deserve to be marked with a dismal “F.” Challenges have mounted for them, making their season feel like a complete waste with minimal progress.
Amidst the A’s and F’s, various teams have earned grades reflecting their rollercoaster journeys. The Los Angeles Rams and Philadelphia Eagles both sit at A-, benefitting from solid quarterback performances, albeit with lingering issues. Meanwhile, teams like the Denver Broncos and Detroit Lions maintain a hopeful outlook, riding strong second-half efforts and organizational resilience.
Conversely, franchises such as the Cleveland Browns and New York Giants, while showcasing flashes of potential with rookies, remain mired in mediocrity. The New Orleans Saints and Cincinnati Bengals are also struggling in their pursuits, facing mounting questions about their futures.
Teams like the Miami Dolphins and New York Jets have opted for a rebuilding approach, hinting at potential brighter days ahead despite current challenges. The Dolphins have recognized the need for change, exploring new directions after parting ways with their general manager, while the Jets look to regroup after dealing away marquee players.
As the NFL season unfolds, each team’s journey continues to surprise, with room for hope for many, while others must confront stark realities. The next half of the season promises more excitement and potential redemption as teams strive to improve their standings and live up to expectations.