EAST LANSING – Jonathan Smith faced another challenging day on Saturday, November 15, as his Michigan State football team fell to Penn State by a score of 28-10, marking their seventh consecutive loss. The aftermath of this defeat had Smith reflecting on the difficulties he has encountered since taking over as head coach, especially given the backdrop of NCAA sanctions impacting the program.
Just days before the loss, it was announced that Smith’s first season would be marred by NCAA violations that occurred under former coach Mel Tucker’s tenure. The NCAA and Michigan State University settled on a resolution that included three years of probation for the program, alongside a $30,000 fine and 1.5% of the football budget due to violations involving impermissible recruiting benefits. Additionally, 14 wins will be vacated from 2022 to 2024, including five victories Smith achieved last year.
In his post-game remarks, Smith was questioned about whether he was aware of the ongoing NCAA investigation when he accepted the position in November 2023. He responded candidly, stating, “No, I did not know,” expressing surprise regarding the circumstances surrounding the violations.
The infractions reportedly began with the school self-reporting a potential Level III violation in June 2023. Subsequent findings revealed that from October 2021 to March 2023, football staff members allegedly provided illegal benefits to recruits, leading to the inquiry into the program. This fallout followed a series of controversies involving Tucker, including his suspension for a Title IX violation related to misconduct allegations.
Smith pointed out the perplexity of how an ineligible player was allowed to compete last season despite adherence to NCAA compliance protocols. He voiced his discontent with the negotiated resolution between the NCAA and MSU, advocating for modernization in the enforcement of penalties. “I think we can modernize – ‘modernize,’ I think, was part of the quote – how penalties are enforced,” he remarked.
As the team navigates the consequences of these sanctions, Smith emphasized the importance of continuing to develop the current roster and upcoming recruiting classes. He remains dedicated to improving the team’s performance and has recognized the hard work by his players despite the challenges. “We want to have some success and win a game. I do think we’re showing that these guys are playing with great effort, and it means a ton to them,” he stated, underlining his commitment to building a resilient and competitive program.
With new athletic director J Batt now overseeing the future of the football program, key decisions regarding Smith’s tenure and the direction of the team are yet to be made. However, Smith’s resolve to persevere through these adversities reflects his dedication to transforming Michigan State football for the better. The hope remains that, with continued effort and a strong recruiting strategy, the Spartans can rise above these setbacks and make significant strides in the seasons to come.