Tua Tagovailoa’s immediate future with the Miami Dolphins is steeped in uncertainty as the team reflects on a challenging 2025 season. The six-year veteran quarterback experienced a significant drop in performance, raising questions about his role moving forward. Head coach Jeff Hafley offered little clarity on the situation, emphasizing that the starting position will ultimately go to the player who best contributes to winning.
In 2025, Tagovailoa struggled throughout the season, posting the worst statistics of his career. His season totals included 260 completions on 384 attempts, accumulating 2,660 yards, along with 20 touchdowns but also 15 interceptions and 30 sacks. This level of performance led to his benching by former head coach Mike McDaniel in Week 16, a decision that saw rookie Quinn Ewers take over the starting role.
During a recent interview on The Jim Rome Show, Hafley acknowledged conversations with Tagovailoa but did not assure him of the starting position for 2026. “This is going to come down to whoever we believe gives us the best chance to win,” Hafley stated, fostering speculation about Tagovailoa’s place on the team.
Hafley’s comments regarding the attributes he seeks in a quarterback further illustrate the team’s position. He expressed a desire for a “winner” with both mental and physical capabilities, suggesting a higher standard that Tagovailoa must meet to secure his spot. “I want a guy who’s got it up here and in his heart,” Hafley added, signifying the importance of leadership qualities in the quarterback position.
Compounding the uncertainty is Tagovailoa’s health, an enduring red flag due to the multiple concussions he has endured throughout his career, including five overall since his college days. His most recent concussion in 2024 resulted in a four-week stint in protocol, raising concerns about his long-term viability.
Despite entering the third year of a lucrative four-year, $212.4 million contract signed in 2024, it remains to be seen if the Dolphins will commit fully to Tagovailoa as their starter. The evolving dynamics within the team could lead to significant changes, leaving fans and analysts alike eager to see how the situation unfolds as the 2026 season approaches. The Dolphins’ hopes for a turnaround hinge not only on Tagovailoa’s performance but also on his ability to secure his health and regain the confidence of the coaching staff.