As the offseason unfolds, the St. Louis Cardinals are evaluating their options regarding their high-priced veterans, particularly Sonny Gray, Nolan Arenado, and Willson Contreras. Gray recently expressed a willingness to waive his no-trade clause after discussions with the new president of baseball operations, Chaim Bloom. His decision has since led to a move to the Boston Red Sox. Arenado, while still with the Cardinals, has indicated he would consider a broader array of teams for a potential trade, although his declining performance and hefty contract make him a complex player to move.
Contreras, who had initially voiced a preference to remain in St. Louis, has also shown a new openness to potential trade deals, particularly if he perceives the receiving team to be a suitable fit. Reports suggest that witnessing the trade of Gray and the rampant speculation surrounding his teammates has motivated Contreras to rethink his stance.
While the Cardinals have been clear about their willingness to trade, Contreras presents somewhat of a unique situation. His contract, which guarantees him $36.5 million over the next two seasons along with a $5 million buyout for a club option in 2028, adds a layer of complexity. At 33 years old, Contreras would find it challenging to command a better deal in free agency currently, making his contractual situation more difficult for the team.
However, Contreras had a solid season, boasting a .257 batting average, 20 home runs, and impressive defensive rankings at first base. His performance could make him appealing to teams in search of a first baseman or designated hitter. The Cardinals may not need to absorb as much of his salary as they did with Gray, but doing so could potentially enhance the return they receive.
Interest in Contreras could come from several clubs struggling with first base and designated hitter positions, including the Red Sox, Rangers, Orioles, Guardians, Mets, Marlins, and Padres. Even teams within the division, like Cincinnati and Pittsburgh, might explore options. The Cardinals would benefit from trading Contreras not only by trimming payroll but also by acquiring prospects to support their rebuilding efforts.
Additionally, trading Contreras would create opportunities for Alec Burleson at first base, along with increased playing time for outfield prospects like Joshua Baez and Nathan Church. With ongoing discussions about potential trades involving other players, including Arenado and several others, the Cardinals are clearly positioning themselves for a transformative offseason as they look to build for the future. The coming weeks will reveal how this ambitious plan unfolds.