Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield took center stage ahead of a high-profile clash against the Buffalo Bills, making it clear that he is not, nor will he ever be, Tom Brady. Following the announcement of the 2025 Walter Payton Man of the Year nominees, Mayfield addressed the constant comparisons with his legendary predecessor, emphasizing his unique approach to football and leadership.
“When you step into a situation like that, when Tom [Brady] has just been there, obviously a living legend, the greatest quarterback that’s ever played, you can’t try and beat him,” Mayfield stated. “Nobody’s ever going to be Tom Brady. There’s not going to be a second one of that.” Instead of viewing himself in the shadow of Brady, Mayfield is committed to being himself, unfiltered and genuine, which has resonated well with Buccaneers fans.
This sentiment echoes back to Mayfield’s initial press conference with the Buccaneers, where he firmly stated, “I’m going to be me.” He believes this authenticity is what brought him success and allows him to engage with the team differently than Brady did. Buccaneers head coach Todd Bowles has also noted that Mayfield’s style and character cannot be compared directly to Brady’s, highlighting how their differences serve to benefit the team.
Where Brady was known for his intense “champion’s mindset,” which some players found demanding, Mayfield aims to foster a more joyful environment. He approaches the game with a focus on camaraderie rather than stress, promoting a fun and engaging atmosphere.
On the field, their styles contrast significantly; Brady excelled as a pocket passer, using elite pre-snap reads, while Mayfield is described as “sneaky athletic” and plays with a gunslinger mentality. His ability to throw off-platform has garnered praise from analysts, who recognize the explosive power in his game that sets him apart from his predecessor.
Mayfield’s recognition as a nominee for the Walter Payton Man of the Year award further cements his role as more than just a player, acknowledging his impactful contributions to the community. Although he ultimately did not win the award— which went to Washington Commanders linebacker Bobby Wagner for his philanthropic efforts—being a finalist was a significant milestone for Mayfield, demonstrating his commitment to excellence both on and off the field.
Through initiatives like his “Be the Ball” event, which raised nearly $600,000 for youth services, and his substantial donations to local causes, Mayfield has proven that his legacy in Tampa extends beyond statistics. His charitable efforts, including providing funds for hurricane relief and equipment for youth sports, illustrate his dedication to the community he now proudly represents. In choosing to carve out his own identity within the Buccaneers, Baker Mayfield is not just following in Tom Brady’s footsteps; he is charting a path that is uniquely his own.