Kay Adams has expressed her admiration for Baker Mayfield’s aggressive style of play, emphasizing the notion of “all gas, no brakes.” However, this intense approach to the game can lead to serious consequences, especially for quarterbacks who are vulnerable to hits from defenders.
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers struggled notably during the second half of the season, falling from a promising 6-2 record to an 8-9 finish that resulted in missing the playoffs. Following the bye week, it became clear that Mayfield was not performing at his usual high standard, leading many, including Joe, to speculate that he was far from healthy. Adams suggested during her weekday show, “Up and Adams” on FanDuel TV, that the Buccaneers should have considered resting Mayfield for a few games to allow him to recuperate. By doing so, he might have been able to return to the field in a more optimal condition.
Adams pointed to the example of San Francisco 49ers coach Mike Shanahan, who successfully managed quarterback Brock Purdy’s situation by prioritizing his health for a strong finish to the season. She questioned whether the Bucs should have done something similar, implying that Mayfield’s commitment to playing through injury might not have been in his or the team’s best interest.
Joe holds a slightly different view, noting the similarities between Mayfield and players like Mac Jones and Purdy. He believes that Jones could be starting for an NFL team this fall, showcasing the depth of talent available. The Bucs’ alternatives when Mayfield was injured, such as Teddy Bridgewater, didn’t provide a viable solution, evidenced by Bridgewater’s struggle during a blowout loss to Los Angeles.
With Mayfield’s dynamic style being crucial to the team’s early successes, it’s evident that the Buccaneers need to reassess their backup quarterback strategy. Ensuring a capable second-string option could help mitigate the risks of relying too heavily on Mayfield, especially if injuries arise again. In doing so, the team might better navigate the challenges of a grueling NFL season while safeguarding the future of their starting quarterback.