Former Minnesota Vikings defensive tackle John Randle has shared his views on the team’s quarterback situation, advocating for the addition of a competent veteran to support 23-year-old J.J. McCarthy. As the Vikings approach the next chapter in their quarterback strategy, Randle has made it clear that he is not in favor of veteran options like Derek Carr or Kirk Cousins.
In an appearance on SKOR North, Randle expressed his concerns about both quarterbacks, stating, “I’m not a big fan of Derek Carr… He retired and then said he wanted to come back, but ultimately he didn’t.” He highlighted the need for an effective management of the game rather than relying on older quarterbacks with uncertain abilities. Randle emphasized that bringing in competition would serve both McCarthy and the team well.
He believes that McCarthy deserves a fair chance but also needs the challenge of a seasoned competitor. “If I were the GM, I would definitely give him competition… We’re gonna bring somebody in who’s definitely gonna give you competition,” Randle said, underlining the importance of not treating the second-string quarterback position as an afterthought.
With free agency on the horizon, Randle suggests a list of potential quarterbacks who could offer that needed support without overshadowing McCarthy. Possibilities include Carson Wentz, Case Keenum, Gardner Minshew, and Jimmy Garoppolo, among others. His preferred candidates reflect a desire for players who can manage games effectively rather than take the starting role outright.
The Vikings had a tumultuous season in 2025, with their quarterback choices drawing criticism after they finished with a 9-8 record, primarily due to subpar performance from Wentz. Randle’s critiques resonate with fans who are eager for a fresh approach in 2026.
The situation is particularly pressing for head coach Kevin O’Connell, who has led the team for four seasons without a playoff win. His leadership may depend on finding a solution to the quarterback conundrum, which might necessitate a significant upgrade from the previous season.
As the offseason unfolds, the question remains: Will the Vikings choose a high-profile quarterback like Kyler Murray or a more stable game manager? Randle’s assertion of requiring a reliable veteran behind McCarthy suggests the Vikings must make strategic decisions to secure a brighter future as they eye playoff success.