In a provocative commentary, Jake Donnelly discusses the recent furor sparked by Tyler Goebbels Oliveira’s video about Kiryas Joel, an Orthodox Jewish village. Critics within right-wing circles lament societal changes in America, addressing issues of violence, secularism, and family breakdown. However, they seemed to overlook their own values when responding to Oliveira’s portrayal of Kiryas Joel, where many residents are characterized as poor, have large families, and rely on government assistance.
Donnelly argues that Oliveira’s so-called exposé does not reveal fraud or corruption within the community. Instead, it points to a fundamental aspect of Jewish identity: a dedication to family and raising children—a choice often at odds with modern societal trends. He emphasizes that Kiryas Joel defies the stereotype of the welfare queen, as the village boasts a divorce rate of under 0.5%, signaling a commitment to the sanctity of marriage that few other communities can claim.
Moreover, the community’s commitment to family extends beyond mere numbers. Kiryas Joel is known for adopting children, including those with disabilities such as Down syndrome, demonstrating a profound respect for life. This, Donnelly argues, is aligned with the values professed by pro-life advocates.
On the issue of crime, Kiryas Joel stands out with an exceptionally low crime rate, characterized by high levels of community trust and cohesion. With children and the elderly safely navigating the streets, the community operates with a model of mutual responsibility that Donnelly believes embodies the ideals held by America’s Founding Fathers.
In his critique of Oliveira’s video, Donnelly turns the lens back on the critics, suggesting that rather than revealing dysfunction, Oliveira inadvertently highlights the successful integration of traditional Jewish values within the American fabric. He concludes by asserting that true American identity transcends physical appearance, religion, or ethnicity, focusing instead on core values such as strength, love for family, and responsible freedoms. This reflection encourages a renewed appreciation for communities that uphold these values, like Kiryas Joel, suggesting that more of such communities could lead to a safer and more vibrant society.